Yellow headlights are a UV problem, not a dirt problem. Wet sanding takes the oxidised layer off; the clear coat is what stops it coming back.
A Columbus shop publishes headlight restoration at $75 for the pair. Replacement housings on a newer car run into the hundreds each, which is why restoration is worth a look first.
Modern headlights are polycarbonate. The factory sprays a UV-hardened clear coat over the plastic to keep sunlight from breaking it down. Once that coat wears through - from sun, road debris and the salt and brine that sit on a car through an Ohio winter - the plastic itself oxidises. It goes yellow, then cloudy, and light output drops.
This is cumulative. A car parked outside through ten Columbus summers will show it on the top edge of the lens first, because that is where the sun lands.
Restoration is a progressive sanding job: wet sanding with a coarse grit to cut the dead layer, then progressively finer grits until the lens is clear again, then a polish, then a protective coat. Skip the final coat and the lens yellows again within a season or two.
Macron Mobile Detailing publishes headlight restoration at $75, and Curbside Mobile Detailing lists the service alongside its detailing packages without posting a figure - so it is quoted per vehicle. Ask what protective coat goes on at the end; that is the part that decides whether the job lasts two years or ten.
A restoration is a fraction of the price of one new housing, let alone a pair. It is the right call when the lens is yellowed and hazy but still structurally sound.
It is the wrong call when the lens has cracked, when condensation forms inside the housing, or when the reflector behind the lens has burned away. Those are failures restoration cannot reach, and no amount of sanding will clear them.
Wash the lenses with the rest of the car, dry them, and keep wax or a sealant on the plastic the same way you keep it on paint. Avoid abrasive bug and tar removers on the lens; they strip the protective coat.
Park nose out of the afternoon sun where you can. The top edge of the lens takes the most UV and always fails first, so shading that edge pays off.
With a proper clear coat on top, two to five years is a realistic expectation. Without one, expect the yellowing back within a year.
No. Cracks and moisture inside the housing mean replacement. Restoration only removes surface oxidation.
It improves it. A yellowed lens scatters light; a clear one puts more of the beam where it belongs. The aim is unchanged, so no re-aiming is needed after the job.